All-Season vs Summer Tyres: Which Suits Australian Roads?

If you drive mostly in warm, dry-to-wet conditions and want the sharpest braking and handling, a summer tyre is the stronger performer. If you want one set that copes with a wider temperature range and tends to last longer, an all-season tyre is the practical choice. In Australia, where snow tyres and seasonal swaps are not part of everyday driving, the real question is simpler: which one matches your car, your roads and the way you drive? Once you know, you can search by your car model or tyre size on Treadivo, pick a local fitter and book the fitting in a single checkout.
TL;DR
- Summer tyres use a softer, grippier compound and shallower tread. In the 2025 test we cite below, the best of them stopped from 100 km/h in 34.2 m against 40.8 m for the worst all-season.
- All-season tyres trade a little dry and wet grip for flexibility across a wider temperature range and, typically, longer tread life.
- Wet-road grip and aquaplaning resistance matter most for Australian storms and hot highways, so judge a tyre on those first.
- Do not pick on the label alone. Check the size on your placard, your annual kilometres and where you drive.
- Buying and fitting does not need to be a two-week job: search, choose a local fitter and check out online.
Table of Contents
- What actually separates the two types
- What the tests say about braking and grip
- Do these results apply on Australian roads?
- Tread life and cost
- Which should you choose?
- Buying the right set without the runaround
- Treadivo for your next set
- Our view on the choice
- FAQ
- Sources
What actually separates the two types
A tyre is a compromise between rubber, tread pattern and temperature. The two categories sit at different points on that compromise.
Summer tyres are built for grip and response in warm conditions. Their compound is soft and sticky, and the tread has fewer grooves and shallower depth, which puts more rubber on the road. Nokian’s technical note describes the same design: less grooving, more rubber in contact and shallower tread for stability when a car is pushed hard. The Popular Mechanics engineer Mac Demere puts the trade-off bluntly: the soft compound is what makes a summer tyre excel on damp roads, and also what makes it harden in the cold.
All-season tyres use a compound designed to stay workable across a broader range of temperatures, and a more siped, blockier tread (siping is the fine slits cut into tread blocks). Those features help in cold, slippery conditions, but MotorTrend, citing tyre-testing specialists, notes they also create compromises on the dry and wet roads most drivers use every day.
Two terms worth knowing before you shop:
- Compound: the rubber mix. Softer means more grip and usually faster wear.
- Aquaplaning: when a layer of water lifts the tyre off the road, so steering and braking stop working. Tread grooves exist to push that water out of the way.
What the tests say about braking and grip
The cleanest recent evidence comes from the 2025 Summer and All Season Combined Tyre Test, which ran both types through the same braking and handling tests.
| Measure (2025 combined test) | Best summer tyres | Worst all-season |
|---|---|---|
| Braking from 100 km/h | 34.2 m | 40.8 m |
| Difference | 6.6 m, or 16.2% longer |
That is the extreme end of the field. The more useful finding is how the result flips with temperature. At +17°C, summer tyres averaged nearly 3 m shorter braking. At +2°C on wet roads, the all-seasons stopped almost 6.5 m shorter. Aquaplaning was the all-seasons’ weakest area: the tested all-seasons lost grip at speeds between 73.2 and 79.4 km/h in the standing-water test.
MotorTrend’s own testing points the same way. On the same vehicle, summer tyres shortened stopping distances and improved cornering grip by 10 to 20 per cent compared with all-seasons, though the higher proportion of rubber to groove improves contact at the cost of more hydroplaning risk in standing water.
What 6.6 metres means in a real stop
Here is our own arithmetic, assuming both cars brake at a constant rate from 100 km/h. When the car on the best summer tyres has come to a complete stop after 34.2 m, the car on the worst all-season tyres is still travelling at roughly 40 km/h. That is the speed at which a pedestrian or a stationary car is seriously injured or damaged. It is a best-versus-worst comparison, so a good all-season will close much of that gap. It does show why braking results deserve more weight than any label.

Do these results apply on Australian roads?
The temperatures in the test are cooler than most of an Australian summer, so treat the numbers as a guide to relative strengths rather than a forecast of your own stopping distance. What carries over is the pattern:
- In warm weather, a summer-biased tyre keeps its grip advantage.
- In cool, wet conditions, an all-season holds up better. That is relevant in Melbourne’s cooler months and on cold mornings in the Perth Hills.
- In heavy rain, tread depth and design matter more than the category name.
RACV’s tyre buying guide describes a huge gap between tyres in maximum grip when accelerating, stopping and cornering, with the gap especially wide in wet conditions. Its expert’s warning is plain: inferior or poorly maintained tyres will not grip as well in the rain. Allianz Australia gives a useful shorthand: all-season tyres perform well in most weather but not extreme conditions, while summer or performance tyres give great grip and handling on dry roads in warm weather. It advises choosing tyres to suit your local climate and driving style.
Tread life and cost
The trade-off reverses on wear. A soft, grippy compound with a shallow tread wears faster, and a performance-focused tyre generally gives up some longevity for grip. All-season tyres usually have moderate tread depth and a compound built to last, which suits drivers who cover a lot of kilometres.
On price, there is no single rule. Which Car’s Australian tyre test found an average RRP of $263 per tyre, with a $190 spread between the cheapest and dearest in the group, and noted that real deal prices were lower. That test dates from 2020, so use it as a picture of how wide the spread is, not as a price list. Brand, size and speed rating shift the price far more than the all-season or summer label does. A 21-inch SUV tyre and a 15-inch hatchback tyre sit in different price worlds.
The cheapest set is not always the cheapest outcome. Divide the price by the kilometres you expect to get, and weigh that against the braking and wet-grip gap RACV warns about. If you are comparing a few options, our guide on when to buy tyres covers wear signs, timing and sale periods in Australia.

Which should you choose?
Use your driving, not the tyre’s marketing, to decide.
| Your situation | Lean towards |
|---|---|
| Mostly warm weather, short city and suburban trips, you value sharp handling | Summer or performance tyre |
| High annual kilometres, want long tread life | All-season or touring tyre |
| Cooler, wetter region such as inland Victoria or the Perth Hills in winter | All-season for flexibility in the cold |
| Sporty or heavier car where braking and cornering matter most | Summer or performance tyre |
| Mixed driving, one set all year, no appetite for managing two sets | All-season |
| Highway-heavy commuting | See our city vs highway tyres guide |
A few checks apply whichever way you go:
- Match your placard. The sticker in the door jamb lists the size, load and speed rating your car was designed for. Our tyre size equivalents guide explains which alternatives are acceptable in Australia.
- Think about the whole set. If you are replacing only some tyres, read mixing tyre brands in Australia first.
- Check the tread you have. Whatever the category, worn tread loses wet grip fastest. An all-season with little tread left will not beat a fresh summer tyre in the rain.
- Consider your vehicle type. EV owners should read our EV tyres guide before changing specification, and 4x4 owners our highway vs all-terrain guide.
A note on snow
If you visit the snowfields, check the rules of the resort and state in which you are driving. Alpine areas have their own requirements for carrying snow chains. This is a safety rule set by the local authority and applies whichever tyre you fit, so confirm it with the resort or the state road authority before the trip.
Buying the right set without the runaround
The hard part of tyre shopping is rarely the choice of category. It is finding the right size for your car, comparing prices that are not itemised and then arranging a fitting slot. A good process removes each of those steps:
- Find the size. Read it off the sidewall (a code such as 235/50R21) or the placard, or search by your car model.
- Narrow to what suits you. Use the table above: your climate, kilometres and priorities.
- Compare like with like. Same size, same speed rating, itemised price.
- Book the fit. A local fitter and a confirmed time, rather than a phone call per workshop.
This is the process Treadivo is built around. You can search by car model or tyre size, see transparent pricing with no hidden fees, choose from local fitters in your area and check out in about three minutes, with same-day fitting confirmation. Our tyre size calculator and AI-powered tread check tool help with the first and third steps, and the augmented reality feature shows how tyres look on your car before you buy.
Treadivo for your next set
Whether you land on a summer-biased tyre or an all-rounder, the sensible next step is to see what is available for your exact car. Search by model or size on our tyre shop, where you can browse passenger, SUV and 4x4, highway, mud terrain, commercial, light truck, truck and motorcycle categories and choose a fitter near you. We have local fitting in Melbourne and Perth, and you can also add an alignment when you book.

Our view on the choice
We think most drivers overthink the label and underthink the fundamentals. The test numbers are clear that tyre design changes stopping distance, and RACV’s warning on wet grip is the one we would put in front of every driver: grip is what you are really buying.
So we start from the car and the roads. Check the size and load rating on your placard, look at the tread you have today, and think honestly about where you drive and how far. For a warm-weather commuter who enjoys driving, a summer-biased tyre is a good fit. For someone covering high kilometres across changing conditions who wants one set and no fuss, an all-season is a reasonable all-rounder.
What we built Treadivo to fix is everything around that choice. Search by your model or size, see the price itemised with no hidden fees, pick a verified local fitter, and have same-day fitting confirmation after a checkout that takes about three minutes. The augmented reality view lets you see the tyres on your own car first, and the tread check tool shows how much life your current set has left.
Choose on grip, wear and your own roads, then let the booking be the easy part.
Areesh
FAQ
Are all-season tyres worth it in Australia?
They suit drivers who want one set to cover a wide range of temperatures and who put a lot of kilometres on the car. Allianz Australia describes them as performing well in most weather but not extreme conditions. Choose by your climate, driving style and the size your car needs.
Do I need to swap tyres between summer and winter?
For most everyday driving in Australian cities, there is no seasonal swap routine to plan around, and one well-chosen set can stay on the car. If you head to the snow, check the chain rules of the resort and state before you go. That rule applies regardless of tyre type.
Do summer tyres wear out faster?
Generally, yes. A soft compound and shallow tread give more grip but less tread life, which is why performance-focused tyres tend to wear sooner than touring and all-season tyres. Wear also depends on your car, alignment, tyre pressure and driving style, so check your tread regularly. You can use our AI-powered tread check tool for that.
How do I find the right size for my car?
Read the size on your tyre sidewall or the placard in the door jamb, or search by your car model on Treadivo. Our size equivalents guide explains which alternative sizes are acceptable in Australia and where the limits sit.
How much do tyres cost?
It varies widely by brand, size and type. A 2020 Australian test recorded RRPs from $160 to $350 per tyre, with real prices lower than the RRP. For a current, itemised price for your size, search on the Treadivo tyre page.
Sources
- 2025 Summer and All Season Combined Tyre Test
- RACV: how to buy the best tyres for your car
- MotorTrend: All-season vs summer tyres
- Popular Mechanics: Know your tyres, all-season vs summer
- Allianz Australia: tyre basics
- Which Car: Wheels tyre test
- Nokian Tyres: summer vs all-season differences
